Sell a Proof American Silver Eagle in NYC | EVB
39 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009·Sun 12:30–6 PM  ·  Mon–Thu 12:30–6:30 PM  ·  Fri 12:30–4 PM  ·  Sat Closed
East Village Buyers

Home › Photos › Proof Silver Eagle

Selling a Proof American Silver Eagle

A proof American Silver Eagle in its capsule, photographed at our counter at 39 Avenue A. Every Silver Eagle holds one troy ounce of .999 fine silver, so the silver sets a floor. Proofs, key dates and graded coins can be worth well past that, and we price each one on what it is.

Proof American Silver Eagle with a W mint mark in a clear capsule, held at East Village Buyers
A West Point proof American Silver Eagle in its capsule at East Village Buyers. From the photos on our Google listing.

What We Look At on a Silver Eagle

Two Silver Eagles with the same silver in them can be priced very differently.

Proof or bullion

Proofs have mirror-like fields with a frosted design and come from the U.S. Mint in a presentation box. They carry a mint mark; the W on this one is West Point. Bullion Silver Eagles have a satin finish and no mint mark.

The year and the design

In mid-2021 the Mint changed the reverse to a new eagle design, so 2021 coins come in two types. A few dates carry big premiums, the 1995-W proof most of all, which was only sold inside an anniversary set.

Box and certificate

A proof in its original Mint box with the certificate of authenticity is easier to resell than a loose capsule. Bring both if you still have them.

Graded coins

Coins graded by PCGS or NGC are priced on the grade on the label, so a PR70 brings more than a PR69.

Before You Bring It In

Leave it in the capsule. Fingerprints and cleaning both show on a proof's mirror surface and lower what a collector will pay. Bring the box, the certificate and any outer sleeve, plus a government-issued photo ID. If you have a run of years, bring them together and we'll price the whole set.

4.8 Stars From 567 Google Reviews

See every photo we've posted, and what customers say about us, on our Google listing.

Common Questions

Selling at 39 Avenue A, explained.

How much silver is in an American Silver Eagle?
One troy ounce of .999 fine silver. That's the floor; proofs and key dates can be worth more.
Is a proof Silver Eagle worth more than a bullion one?
Usually, yes. Proofs are made in smaller numbers for collectors and sell for more than their silver, especially in the original box with the certificate.
Do you buy graded Silver Eagles?
Yes. PCGS and NGC coins are priced on the grade and the date. Bring them as they are; don't crack them out of the holder.
Can I get a quote before I come in?
Text a photo of the coin and the box label to 917-608-8939 and we'll give you a ballpark.

Ready When You Are

39 Avenue A (between E 2nd & E 3rd St), East Village · Walk-ins welcome · Sun 12:30–6 · Mon–Thu 12:30–6:30 · Fri 12:30–4

About five minutes from the F train at Second Avenue.

Text Photos for a Quote39 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009 Call 917-608-8939 Get Directions