Selling a Proof American Silver Eagle
A proof American Silver Eagle in its capsule, photographed at our counter at 39 Avenue A. Every Silver Eagle holds one troy ounce of .999 fine silver, so the silver sets a floor. Proofs, key dates and graded coins can be worth well past that, and we price each one on what it is.

What We Look At on a Silver Eagle
Two Silver Eagles with the same silver in them can be priced very differently.
Proof or bullion
Proofs have mirror-like fields with a frosted design and come from the U.S. Mint in a presentation box. They carry a mint mark; the W on this one is West Point. Bullion Silver Eagles have a satin finish and no mint mark.
The year and the design
In mid-2021 the Mint changed the reverse to a new eagle design, so 2021 coins come in two types. A few dates carry big premiums, the 1995-W proof most of all, which was only sold inside an anniversary set.
Box and certificate
A proof in its original Mint box with the certificate of authenticity is easier to resell than a loose capsule. Bring both if you still have them.
Graded coins
Coins graded by PCGS or NGC are priced on the grade on the label, so a PR70 brings more than a PR69.
Before You Bring It In
Leave it in the capsule. Fingerprints and cleaning both show on a proof's mirror surface and lower what a collector will pay. Bring the box, the certificate and any outer sleeve, plus a government-issued photo ID. If you have a run of years, bring them together and we'll price the whole set.
More From Our Counter
Other pieces from the photos on our Google listing.
Air Jordan 1 Court PurpleWith the box, in front of the sneaker wall
Louis Vuitton SpeedyMonogram canvas with a honey patina
Moncler puffer jacketGlossy blue down, logo patch on the chest
Dior B22 sneakersDior's chunky runner in a blue print
4.8 Stars From 567 Google Reviews
See every photo we've posted, and what customers say about us, on our Google listing.