Compare · Sneakers & Streetwear
StockX & GOAT vs Selling Locally in NYC
Short answer: for a new, unworn pair in a size that sells, StockX or GOAT will usually net you more than a cash offer, even after fees. Selling locally wins on speed and certainty: no fees, no shipping, no verification risk, worn pairs welcome, and cash the same day. Here is the fee math as published in November 2026, so you can decide.
- Same-day cash
- Checked in front of you
- Walk-ins welcome
- Trade toward store stock
The Fees
What StockX and GOAT Charge Sellers
These are the published rates for a US seller who is just starting out. StockX's fee drops as you reach higher seller levels. GOAT's rises if your seller rating falls from cancellations.
| StockX (Verified Marketplace) | GOAT | |
|---|---|---|
| What it takes | Brand-new items only, free from signs of use | New and used items; sellers must be approved first |
| Selling fee | 9% transaction fee at Level 1, falling to 7% at Level 5; $5 minimum seller fee | 9.5% commission with a seller rating of 90 or above; 15% to 25% at lower ratings |
| Processing | 3% payment processing fee | 2.9% cash-out fee when you move earnings to a bank or PayPal |
| Shipping | $5 seller shipping fee, taken from your payout (free at some drop-off locations) | $5 seller fee with a prepaid label; $0 if you drop off |
| Ship deadline | 2 business days after the sale | 3 business days after the order |
| When you're paid | After the item passes verification, in that evening's daily payout | Earnings post after verification; banks take 3 to 5 business days after you cash out |
| Penalties | $15 for shipping late; a verification-failure fee if it fails | $10 if you cancel or ship late; $15 if an item is deemed a replica |
Sources: StockX seller fees, seller shipping, ship time, shipping instructions and payouts; GOAT Fee Policy and Selling with GOAT (both last updated August 1, 2026). As published in November 2026. Fees change often, so check each page before you list.
Worked Example
One $300 Pair, Three Ways
A new, unworn pair that sells for $300, from a new US seller using the platform's shipping label. This is what reaches your bank, and what has to happen first. We added eBay because its published sneaker fee is the lowest of the three.
| StockX | GOAT | eBay | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sale price | $300.00 | $300.00 | $300.00 |
| Selling fee | −$27.00 (9%) | −$28.50 (9.5%) | −$24.00 (8%), plus 8% of any sales tax the buyer pays |
| Other fees | −$9.00 (3% processing) | −$5.00 (seller fee) | None at $150 or more |
| Shipping | −$5.00 | Covered by the seller fee | Free label to eBay's authenticator |
| Cash-out fee | None listed | −$7.73 (2.9% of $266.50) | $2.00 only if you choose express payout |
| Net to you | $259.00 | $258.77 | $276.00, less the fee on tax |
| Paid after | It ships, arrives and passes verification | It passes verification and you cash out | Usually within 48 hours of the buyer's payment; new sellers wait until about 2 days after delivery |
We apply StockX's 3% processing fee to the sale price; StockX's page doesn't say what it's calculated on, so check your payout screen. Dropping off at GOAT instead of using the prepaid label saves the $5 seller fee. eBay rates are from its selling fees, Authenticity Guarantee and payment holds pages. That net, minus the wait and the risk, is the number to weigh a cash offer against. A local cash offer will usually be lower. What it buys you is the money today, with nothing left that can go wrong.
Time, Risk, Effort
What the Fee Table Doesn't Show
The percentage is only part of the cost of selling online. Here is the rest.
- Waiting for a buyer
- Your pair sells when a buyer meets your price. A popular size can go fast; a slow one can sit, and the market price can move while it does.
- Shipping deadlines
- Once it sells, StockX gives you 2 business days to ship and GOAT gives you 3. Miss it and the order can be canceled, with a $15 penalty on StockX or $10 on GOAT.
- Verification risk
- Both platforms inspect the pair before you're paid. If it fails, the buyer is refunded and you can owe a fee. On GOAT, flaws found at inspection, like scuffs or missing laces, lead to a request to lower your price.
- Condition limits
- StockX's Verified Marketplace takes only brand-new items. Worn pairs need GOAT (with photos), StockX's Listings Marketplace, which is open only to select sellers for now, or a local buyer.
- Days, not minutes
- The money arrives after shipping, transit, inspection and a payout cycle, and on GOAT, a bank transfer after you cash out.
- Selling at the counter
- We check the pair in front of you, make an offer and pay the same day if you take it. No fees come off, nothing ships, and worn pairs are fine. You can also trade toward something in the store.
Streetwear
What About Grailed and Worn Pieces?
For streetwear, Grailed is the usual online option. It's peer-to-peer: you list the piece, set the price and ship it to the buyer. As published in November 2026, Grailed's seller fee is 9% on sales of $120 or more and 6% under $120 (minimum $1.99). Payment processing adds 3.49% plus $0.49 on US payments for sellers onboarded with Stripe. On a sale over $120, that's about 12.5% plus 49 cents before your shipping cost.
StockX also has a Listings Marketplace for used items. At launch it charges sellers zero fees, but selling access is limited to select US sellers.
On worn pieces, condition moves the price more than the platform does. Read how stains, fading and print cracking and a missing or damaged box change what buyers pay, wherever you sell.
The Honest Answer
When StockX or GOAT Is the Better Call
If the pair is new and you can wait, the platforms usually put more money in your pocket. We'd rather tell you that than pretend otherwise.
- New and unworn, in the original box, in a size that sells steadily
- You can wait a week or more for the money
- You're fine packing, shipping on a deadline and handling a verification problem if one comes up
- The gap between the online net and a cash offer is worth that time to you
Sell Locally
When Selling Locally Makes More Sense
For some sellers, cash today beats a bigger number later.
- The pair is worn, creased, yellowed or missing its box
- You need the money today, not after verification
- You don't want shipping deadlines, penalties or a failed inspection
- You're selling several pairs, or sneakers and streetwear together
- You want to trade toward something in our store